Elsinore Review: Andrew Scott Is More Than Worthy of Best Actor With Heartbreaking True Story
One of the most beautifully devastating stories you'll see all year.
This post is free to enjoy but the rest of the series is exclusive to Gold Star Crew members.
🌟Supporters like: Jo Uhrich, Andrew F. Peirce, Wendy Zaballos, Nadine Whitney, Altus Lee, Libeth Morales, Lucy May, David Fox, Alexandra Bowser, and Jacob Haller💫
🚨November is a month of deals for new paid subs! Any new paid subscribers receive a free digital copy of my book Popcorn Disabilities. And all new annual subscribers get an additional mystery book mailed direct from my bookcase! We also have our next Gold-level Zoom mixer on November 13th to discuss our first ever Secret Santa Gift exchange! Join the Gold Star crew to get in on the fun.🚨
Paid subscribers are the backbone of The Film Maven who support independent journalism, as well as female- and disabled-created content. Paid Film Mavens get access to shout-outs, exclusive articles and series, career mentoring, Zoom mixers, and access to The Film Maven Discord.
Consider becoming a paid subscriber and joining the community that invests in independent journalism free of AI and influencer opinions!
As a child of the '90s, I can recall countless TV shows and films about HIV and AIDS. Movies focused on the tragedy and heartbreak of watching young men die en masse from a disease people didn't, or refused to, understand. Now, as AIDS has transitioned away from being an instant death sentence to a manageable chronic disease, it's harder for me to explain to younger film lovers what these films meant. And I worried upon seeing Elsinore that it would be a simple, old-fashioned AIDS story. How wrong I was.
Elsinore is an AIDS narrative, yes. But it takes that and masterfully blends it with an exploration of how art (theater specifically, but also movies) helps us cope with life's horrors. Nurtured in the hands of Andrew Scott, the story of British actor Ian Charleson is one that feels truly life-affirming. It doesn't wring the tears out of you so much as it draws them out (copiously). Elsinore becomes an utterly beautiful and devastating movie about AIDS while simultaneously being an entertaining story about an actor who struggled to find himself and rise above the box Hollywood put him in.
Set in 1989, Ian Charleson (Scott) is an actor struggling to maintain his standing in Hollywood after finding success in the 1981 feature Chariots of Fire. When Daniel Day-Lewis abandons a run of Hamlet at the National Theatre Ian is tapped to take his place. While this might finally be his chance to prove himself, Ian also knows he has AIDS. Determined to play Hamlet, he hides his condition, frustrating his doctor Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman) who believes a silly play isn't worth giving his life for.
Screenwriter Stephen Beresford crafts a film that places theater at its center, starting with the opening scenes of the National Theatre's Hamlet wherein Daniel Day-Lewis (whose face is never seen) leaves the stage, and the production entirely. The theater world in England is one of legitimacy, with a rich legacy, and it's something that Ian believes he'll never return to. Determined to go out and make movies, we meet Charleson as he's struggled to avoid being labeled the Chariots of Fire star. People routinely sing the popular theme song and remind him of it, every memory a reminder that he's no longer relevant.

There is this fascinating underpinning of legacy being at odds with popularity that simmers underneath everything. Ian grimaces every time he's associated with the movie, yet it something people have remembered him as participating in. Yet he quests to return to a medium where he can stretch his talents and when National Theatre director Richard Eyre (Johnny Flynn giving off strong Richard Burton vibes) asks him to replace Day-Lewis Ian initially sees it as a chance for people to remember he's a talented performer.
This being 1989, AIDS is an established thing and it's something every gay man in Ian's orbit is on the lookout for. Beresford and director Simon Stone don't present a world of fear and apprehension, where men are looking at each other askance at every opportunity. Ian and his friends are still out living life, falling in love (or, in Ian's case, being afraid of commitment) with the knowledge that AIDS is out there. A group of men clad in nun habits routinely dispense condoms on the streets as well as providing medical advice and doctor recommendations. It's a lush and lived in world of friendship and camaraderie trying to manage with this specter of AIDS inhabiting the same space. Ian himself is living with this same ghost, albeit trying to figure out if his HIV has moved into the AIDS stages. We meet him doing a daily routine of checking his body for Kaposi's sarcoma.
Andrew Scott is a phenomenal actor, we know this. And yet he's on an entirely different level of brilliance here. He's charming yet aloof in the early sequences of him traipsing through gay bars and other areas where the LGBTQ community reside. Ian's world is intentionally small, composing mainly of him and his best friend/casting agent Patsy (Billie Piper) and her daughter, as well as friend Sean (Matthew Beard). Once he's officially given the diagnosis of AIDS he's forced to make that circle wider while trying to keep his diagnosis quiet from the rest of the production. Scott makes Ian so magnetic that it's impossible not to be drawn to him, like a moth to a flame.
Yet for all that, Scott never hides the fear and apprehension Ian holds, being a closeted gay man torn between popularity and being authentic. Scott's sequences with David Dawson as director Derek Jarman lay out the dichotomy of whether it's responsible for a gay man to hide his sexuality, especially at a time when they're dying in secret. Beresford's script never answers this question, but it's something that we still don't discuss enough in Hollywood. As Ian says, he refuses to be a victim, and to disclose his diagnosis (and his sexuality), he believes would make him so. He just wants to act.

Similarly, his commitment to acting puts him at odds with Olivia Colman's Margaret Johnson. Colman's portrayal of the doctor is one of cold formality. Johnson tells Ian to immediately leave the show. As he gets sicker, she finds it repugnant that his friends would encourage him to continue. Her side is ride, yet it's easy to understand why Ian is so committed to performing. Acting is what is keeping him alive, just as art keeps the other residents of the community hospital he's staying in alive. He, alongside a young AIDS patient named Nicholas (Joe Locke), perform a rendition of Ethel Merman's "There's No Business Like Show Business" that even convinces Margaret of art's efficacy.

And it is the beauty of art that comes through so wonderfully in Elsinore. There are moments of huge emotion, particularly as Ian gets sicker, and yet Scott never lets that diminish his (and Ian's) power over their circumstances. The Hamlet sequences are some of the most emotionally resonant scenes you'll watch all year. Editor Valerio Bonelli's montages, illustrating how the power of Shakespeare's words convey the emotion Ian feels as he gets weaker, coupled with Stefan Gregory's pounding score is breathtaking. It's impossible not to see how art connects with us as Ian screams "Fie," unleashing all the anger and hurt of the world he's living in. Charleson's performance was never filmed, so that, coupled with Scott having performed Hamlet himself, leaves the audience to see a true melding of actor and performance.
Give Andrew Scott the Oscar, plain and simple. He's utterly fabulous as is the rest of the movie. A heartbreaking yet life-affirming story of a man who was more than the one role he played. It's also a great attempt to try to tell a new type of AIDS narrative in a world that treats the disease so differently. Pack your tissues and be dazzled.
Grade: A
Elsinore is in theaters Friday.
If you liked this review, paid Film Mavens get the stuff I can't publish anywhere else:
- Access to all my paid content and exclusive series like:


- Shout outs on my newsletter when you join and whenever you have something you're launching.
- Included on my Gold Star Crew list
- Bi-Monthly Zoom Mixers where we can talk entertainment, get advice on journalism, and generally discuss the world.
- Access to our Discord server where we can chat about movies and entertainment. It's also where I host my yearly Golden Globes and Oscar watches.
- Participation in my new Film Maven Secret Santa Gift Exchange (launching November 13, 2026), book clubs, and film discussion groups (launching later in 2027)

