Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth Review: Fincher and Tarantino Get Lost in the City of Angels
Brad Pitt can't overcome a shaggy script lost in its aimlessness
This post is free to enjoy but the rest of the series is exclusive to Gold Star Crew members.
🌟Supporters like: Mark Murphy, Tasya Swisko, Sandeep Chandowalia, Elissa Farkas, Kiahamarafisch, Jason Reynal, Lawrence Carter-Long, Media Path Podcast, Shupei, and Ethan Luce💫
🚨November is a month of deals for new paid subs! Any new paid subscribers receive a free digital copy of my book Popcorn Disabilities. And all new annual subscribers get an additional mystery book mailed direct from my bookcase! We also have our next Gold-level Zoom mixer on November 13th to discuss our first ever Secret Santa Gift exchange! Join the Gold Star crew to get in on the fun.🚨
Paid subscribers are the backbone of The Film Maven who support independent journalism, as well as female- and disabled-created content. Paid Film Mavens get access to comments and shout-outs, exclusive articles and series, career mentoring, Zoom mixers, and access to The Film Maven Discord.
Consider becoming a paid subscriber and joining the community that invests in independent journalism free of AI and influencer opinions!
In 2019, director Quentin Tarantino introduced audiences to Cliff Booth, an affable, yet deadly, stuntman in his feature Once Upon a Time...in Hollywood. Booth, alongside Leonardo DiCaprio – as his professional and hetero life mate Rick Dalton – gave the movie a wholly original and fun exploration of Los Angeles in the late-1960s in a movie that also gave a revisionist history to the Manson family killings of 1969. Returning to that world with a sequel, The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth leaps forward eight years, to 1977, with Tarantino handing the director reins to David Fincher.
Fincher provides a slick, California cool to the proceedings, but the end result is an aimless hodgepodge that doesn't know what to do. The episodic nature of the film feels more like a backdoor pilot for a far superior, and more in-depth, television series. Cliff Booth feels like a different character this time around, retconning much of what audiences learned about him in the first film. The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth will just have you asking why Tarantino didn't stick with that film critic movie he was pitching.
Cliff Booth (Brad Pitt) has put his stuntman days behind him, for the most part. Now, he's mostly doing favors for Hollywood bigwigs while caring for his aging father (Peter Weller). When a prominent television star (Scott Caan) asks Booth for a favor involving some Filipino gangsters, it'll take all of Booth's charm and aggression to save the day.
The above plot synopsis is highly truncated as, for the majority of Cliff Booth's two hour and twenty minute runtime there's very little story. The opening sequence, set at Tarantino's New Beverly Theater, introduces Booth and his makeshift role as something passing for a Hollywood fixer. It's unclear whether this is a job he's been doing routinely for the last eight years since Rick Dalton "got fat" and moved to Australia, especially as the movie introduces Booth in a variety of other jobs (including a porn star past that would have been a far more interesting narrative). Gone is any reference to Brandy, Booth's faithful dog from the first film, or really any of his backstory introduced in that, short of Rick. Even the Manson Family stuff is boiled down to one reference to some "hippies" he killed.

It's not that chronic references to the first feature are needed, but it leads to an overall feeling that much of the Booth presented in the first movie has been erased for this go-round. (It's worth pointing out that the first movie was released by Sony, not Netflix.) Pitt gives this new Booth a pronounced Southern accent and a general doofiness that was absent the last time. Here, he spends his days hanging out with his dad and leaving random radio dedications to him, and others, he has a love for. If you didn't have the first movie in your head, and know what Booth is capable of, you'd assume the guy is an utter dullard. Pitt certainly brings a lot of charm and swagger to the role, but that's about it.
The film advertises itself as a love letter to '70s cinema and the Los Angeles of that time. The wandering plot could certainly feel akin to the likes of 1973's The Long Goodbye – which gets referenced on the New Beverly marquee – or even 1966's Harper. But those two movies are clear-cut detective films and there's no detecting here. Everyone claims to recognize Booth, though it's never specified if that has to do with being a stunt man, a porn star, a bartender or murdering the Manson Family, and he's a go-to guy for problems. But this never feels like something he's been cultivating for the last eight years. He's a man with no mission, no purpose, as much as the movie desperately wants us to think he has one.
Where the first feature lovingly recreated large swaths of Los Angeles, including Hollywood Boulevard, there's nothing on that same level with Cliff Booth. If anything, this movie feels smaller despite the prodigious $200 million dollar price tag; the original had a budget of $90-96 million. There's an insular quality to this film, wherein Cliff and his friends spend less time cruising the streets and more just hanging out in buildings. The replication of the past that looked so beautiful in the first feature is wholly unknown here, especially as Cliff spends his time in wealthy enclaves like the Malibu Colony or various high end clubs. Who knows how much those places have changed. Not like the average Joe living in that time would have been there.
As Booth wanders from his house to a club to his house again, the movie begs for something to happen. At some point the audience is introduced to gangsters Fernando and Eddie (TB Tadena and Matt Groove, respectively) as they're set to enact vengeance on a woman who has wronged them. The few stray moments of extreme violence are where Fincher's flair behind the camera comes through, albeit it does feel like we're entering an entirely different movie. As the pair stalk through the palatial Hollywood estate, leaving carnage in their wake, Erik Messerschmidt's gorgeous cinematography showcases the interplay of the dark shadows on the pristine white walls of the house. There's a fluidity and a grace as Taden and Groove move through the space, grousing about things, that feels akin to Tarantino's Vincent and Jules from Pulp Fiction.

Unfortunately, once these two are introduced they don't return till the final 45-odd minutes of the movie, wherein the plot finally, thankfully, develops. Eventually, Cliff is hired by talent agent Karen Crosby (Elizabeth Debicki) to help popular Western television hero, Caan's Charlie Peters, with an accidental problem he's created that involves Eddie and Fernando. It's a rather asinine plot that develops so quickly and is hard to really care about. Caan feels very much like a Temu Rick Dalton, if only because he gets the exact same buildup as DiCaprio did in the first feature. We get loving recreations, and the only source of narration, of Peters's career that are fun. But the introduction of this catalyst is just mostly an opportunity for Cliff to be charming, having had a past with Charlie's wife Toni (a wasted Carla Gugino), and engaging in a slap-happy romance with Debicki's character.
Cliff Booth worked as part of an ensemble, and he's only as good as the people standing next to him. Pitt was part of a trio of the biggest stars in 2019, with DiCaprio and Margot Robbie. Here, Pitt carries everything, so he both dominates the frame and smothers everyone else around him. No one character, short of Caan, has any type of history so there's little to latch onto short of the individual performer. Caan plays Charlie as an arrogant narcissist. One eager to learn about killing but then crying over a pig he's chosen to kill. He brings some levity in his blubbering but he's a plot device, little more. Gugino is just there to be told how pretty she is and act as an unwitting lady in peril.

Debicki, having done such fantastic work in Wicker this year, tries hard to find something to hold onto as Karen Crosby. Clad exclusively in white, Karen doesn't have much going on beneath the surface. A stray reference to a relationship with another man is one of many threads introduced that goes nowhere. There's little real chemistry between Debicki and Pitt, and their contentious relationship leaves the viewer feeling Cliff is trying way too hard and Karen just gave up by the end. The standouts are Tadena and Groove as the Verdusco brothers. It's possible they shine because their moments feel the most Fincher-esque, but they are utterly perfect. They're cold and calculating, and their sequence opposite Booth in the finale is the most crackling moment in the entire feature. There's such tension, alongside some brilliant stunt effects, that it'll leave you asking why the entire movie couldn't have this sense of momentum.
Nothing really gels in The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth. A patchwork structure of situations sees Booth and crew wandering in search of a story. The rest of the cast never feel like anything more than pieces on a storyboard, and Booth has little chemistry with any of them. Tadena and Groove are great, as is Fincher's flair for the old ultra-violence, but they feel inserted in from a far more interesting movie. It's not unwatchable, but expect to drift into wanting to watch Once Upon a Time...in Hollywood instead.
Grade: D+
The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth hits theaters November 25 and streams on Netflix December 23.
If you liked this review, paid Film Mavens get the stuff I can't publish anywhere else:
- Access to all my paid content and exclusive series like:


- Shout outs on my newsletter when you join and whenever you have something you're launching.
- Included on my Gold Star Crew list
- Bi-Monthly Zoom Mixers where we can talk entertainment, get advice on journalism, and generally discuss the world.
- Access to our Discord server where we can chat about movies and entertainment. It's also where I host my yearly Golden Globes and Oscar watches.
- Participation in my new Film Maven Secret Santa Gift Exchange, book clubs, and film discussion groups (launching later in 2027)

